NPR Labs Weighs in on IBOC Coverage, Interference
ecent publication and distribution of NPR Lab's Digital Radio Coverage and Interference Analysis Research Project (DRCIA) seems to reiterate a point once made by renown physicist Albert Einstein, when he suggested we ought to “make everything as simple as possible - but not simpler.”
The comprehensive report, commissioned by the Corporation for Public Broadcasing in 2006 to answer question about IBOC DAB coverage, is a meaty piece of work. At almost 280 pages, it requires time to digest, which explains why project manager John Kean and other key NPR personnel have taken time to present their findings over an NPR closed circuit and at a Public Radio Engineering Conference in Austin, TX, just ahead of the NAB Radio Show.
According to NPR, CPB funded the DRCIA project with the primary goal of determining real-world coverage of analog FM and hybrid IBOC digital radio services, as well as interference occurring within and between both families of service. The study was recommended to the CPB in 2005, well before discrepancies in digital signal coverage had emerged as a significant issue in digital radio's rollout.
Laying the foundation
In their early phases of inquiry, it became obvious to NPR engineers that a better understanding of marketplace receiver performance was essential to building a profile of hybrid IBOC DAB coverage and interference issues. After testing and characterizing a sizeable number of both analog and HD Radio receivers, a mobile test bed was used to generate measured analog service coverage maps on a number of NPR stations around the country. Building on this work, researchers constructed similar field measurement sets using actual digital receivers and leveraged that data into the first predictive computer model for IBOC digital coverage.
Eventually, NPR Labs was able to generate both digital and analog coverage maps based on real-world receiver data and measured fields for 850 NPR stations nationwide – a remarkable achievement. In addition, 75 of these stations had their digital coverage analyzed using both the normally licensed value of 1 percent IBOC digital power, versus an elevated level of 10 percent. The latter level corresponds directly to an increase recently proposed to the FCC by the NAB and other interested parties.
Because the studies were detailed and relied on actual receiver data, an unprecedented multi-dimensional model of coverage based on analog/digital signal levels, as well as the effects of co-channel and adjacent channel analog/digital interference, emerged.
Among the points raised during the DRCIA project, one central observation stands out: Digital versus analog coverage ratios for IBOC hybrid stations are both individualized and variable, with interference playing a significant role in many cases.
Just as real-world digital transmissions don't operate in an RF vacuum, neither do digital RF components, particularly low-level sidebands occupying spectrum beyond traditionally defined channel limits. Thus, much of the variability in IBOC digital service coverage is linked to a couple key factors.
While raw field strength of digital carriers is important, the study suggests that first-adjacent channel interference is a significant player in the successful capture and decoding of digital signals. While FM IBOC digital signals can survive a considerable amount of interference from either an upper or lower 1st adjacent channel, simultaneous interference both above and below can degrade receiver performance by as much as an additional 10dB beyond that of a single interferer. This means that stations with short-spaced first-adjacent channels or in crowded urbanized markets may find their digital coverage well below expectation.
The DRCIA report looks at an IBOC digital signal's impact on adjacent channel analog reception as well. Even at current 1 percent levels, the interference potential of an IBOC digital signal for adjacent analog channels is significantly higher than that of an analog-only signal, while a 10dB increase in digital carrier power has a major impact on reception of adjacent channel analog signals. Tables of desired-to-undesired signal ratios for indoor, outdoor and portable receivers provided in the DRCIA final report make these points in striking fashion. One table is included here as Table 1.
Acceptable Use Policy blog comments powered by Disqus
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Today in Radio History
The history of radio broadcasting extends beyond the work of a few famous inventors.
EAS Information More on EAS
The feed provides feeds for all US states and territories.
Need a calendar for your computer desktop? Use one of ours.
Information from manufacturers and associations about industry news, products, technology and business announcements.
After 57 years in the same building, CKUA was ready for a move. But it hasn't forgotten its history.
Browse Back Issues[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Also in the June Issue
- The Radio magazine Pick Hits of the 2013 NAB Show
- The Settlement/Amendment Process for FM Translators
- Side by Side: Headphones
- Field Report: iZotope Insight
- Field Report: Rode iXY
- Better Coaxial Cable Runs
- 20 Years of Radio magazine: July 1994